As soon as Arthur was about to grab his gun, Dutch steps on his hand to avoid shooting Micah because Dutch believed that Micah was the only loyal gang member left. Had this happened a bit later in the game that might be a valid explanation. If Micah had been in on the capture of Arthur, how would he have convinced Colm to let him leave the parlay with Dutch? Dutch did treat Colms execution as nothing more than a loose end despite being rivals for years. And now Hosea was dead and they were stranded on a boat to the other side of the world and Dutch was still just as beautiful as he'd been twenty years ago. Mount your horse, and ignore the path east that the waypoint gives you. Meester Lee said: Unwilling immigrants to Westeros, firearms, invasive species.. things are going to get . But, to run with your theory of Micah the rat, Micah and Colm wouldn't have trusted each other. Arthur doesn't die; Dutch listens to his people not the rat; The rat dies; Depression; Anger; Language: English Stats: Published: 2022-12-17 Updated: 2023-02-28 . The two realized they could put their skills together and become rich. Dutch is pretty much defenseless: there's him, Micah and Arthur and Micah is a turncoat that sold Arthur out. Some bits of information are openly displayed in cutscenes, whereas others are more subtle. Today, we'll dig up some little known facts about him. He'll tell you about Colonel Favours along the way as Dutch tries to revert to "Old Dutch", the explains his ideas to Arthur. Which was something that didn't sit well with Arthur as the game started. And then when John fell off the train, he took it yet again. And the reason Dutch left him to die is kind of the whole point of the game. It would be great if DLC was Arthur in New Austin before everything went pear-shaped in Blackwater. I had the same problem thats why I was on this sight lol, hope it helped! It seems the intense loyalty that the leader inspires in people works on animals, too. The grave of Dutch's mother can be found in the cemetery of Blackwater. And now this leaving arthur to die because he thinks arthur is on his way. For instance, you can learn plenty of little details about the character just by keeping your ears and eyes open, even while just walking around your camp. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. One of the first upgrades players end up getting will likely be Dutchs personal camp. This was likely Dutchs attempt to create some distance between the gang and Pinkertons. I guess he would play me in a second as well.. Press J to jump to the feed. He wanted to beat Dutch, to prove he was the better leader, the better man. This is one of the rarer horses in the game. NEXT: Red Dead Online: 10 Collector Tips Everyone Should Know. RELATED: Red Dead Redemption 2: The 10 Most Craziest Random Encounters You Probably Missed. Choose your moment and press / to perform a Stealth Kill. good for you tbh, hardest thing in the game is to get a chubby arthur. Maybe they returned camp in order to get Javier? And he had that as soon as he captured Arthur/the sniper position. When Dutch killed Colm by botching his rescue, it was because he no longer would "play the game": Colm had tried to turn Dutch over to the Pinkertons instead of keeping the fight going, "betraying" him. An alias is only natural. One thing is that Dutch probably didnt know that Arthur was captured. Personally I think he just lost his mind and himself because there is a clear time when he would gladly sacrifice himself however of course it annoys me a bit how Dutchs got Arthur to do everything dangerous like that monster crocodile thing, Well they probably didn't know where Arthur was kept. He doesnt say it out loud to him, but the vibe changes. Thanks mister. It is genuinely worth discussing as even Hoseas name can be seen in the ledger, and often at that. dont feel that yet either. Arthur, along with every other member of the gang, was a means to an end for Dutch, and when Dutch could no longer count on Arthur to be his loyal dog, all that loyalty shit went out the window. 1910-2010. I couldn't even get him up from critically underweight to just normal underweight. That's why he left John too, he suspected that he was the rat, and with him in police custody, Dutch thought he could continue to observe and figure out if word of their plans kept getting out while John was behind bars. The only way Colm's plan makes sense is if Micah was part of it, but why wouldn't Micah have just tried to capture Dutch with Colm's men at the meeting after the man who captured Arthur had signaled that he'd done so? Pearson brings news that Colm ODriscoll has requested a parley. Arthur Morgan is a central character and the primary protagonist of Red Dead Redemption 2. InRed Dead Redemption II, Colm and Dutch meet to try to form a type of peace. There would have been nothing to stop him killing Micah. Arthur even mentiones as much when talking to Dutch afterwards, saying he doesn't think the guy stands much of a chance. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Go around the wooden structure to the right, and move towards the guard on the path. Dude i just ecpirenced this scene for the first time, im high asf and it kinda hurt me, really cut deep, I feel you! And why? RELATED: The Best Horses In Video Game History. ), but rather that someone else, perhaps another gang, did. Dutch never seems to do something himself so he probably had the other men looking for Arthur. Colm told Arthur that he wanted to set a trap so that Dutch and the gang would be caught and he could then bargain with the law, the Van der Linde gang for his gangs freedom. Yes. Red Dead Redemption 2 is a 2018 action-adventure game developed and published by Rockstar Games. Logically, he wouldn't and Colm is never characterised as stupid. As you start to go up the stairs, you will automatically stop as two ODriscoll guards pass the doorway above you going in opposite directions. But Colm didn't want Dutch dead -- he wanted his old friend to suffer. There should be one other guard in the immediate area, to the west of you. Or is there something Im missing? He is deeply remorseful but can't admit it because he is too arrogant and proud to admit what he did wrong. Micah reveals that the plan is to have Arthur cover them from above while Micah and Dutch go to the meeting. This killing came in retaliation after Dutch killed Colm's brother. Your email address will not be published. They were waiting til first light to try and follow your tracks. I like to think that everyone that died up until then would have chosen Arthurs side (Hosea, Lenny and Saun). This is likely a reference to the Battle of Gettysburg, one of the few battles that took place in Pennsylvania. 4 Dutch Never Donates His Own Money To The Camp RELATED: 10 Red Dead Redemption 2 Memes That Every Player Can Relate To. RDR2 is very similar, but it is aware of said similarities and uses them as a strength. And the law will be waiting for him." After a few more hits to his ribs, Colm left Arthur and Isaac alone in the basement. So, they keep fighting to a standoff, building their strength, never delivering the killing blow and dividing the law's attention between them, spreading their resources against two gangs and prolonging their idea of the Wild West. What do I know? "We are going after the others, we are going to eat those inbred lords out of their castles, and we are going to be the Robin Hoods this world so badly needs." . Although Arthur does have a biological father who raised him for quite some time, he's more a son of Dutch and Hosea than anything else. Follow behind him until you can stealthily take him out. Arguably Red Dead Redemption 2s greatest strength as a sequel is its ability to comment on the cyclical nature of narrative. Its possible the sniper took a shot on Dutch and missed and they got away, I suppose. Thanks for the reply mister, you have a fine day now. Covering the hottest movie and TV topics that fans want. Interestingly, Aiden OMalley is also the name of one of Niko Bellics supporting players in Grand Theft Auto 4. "Dutch will be here soon. Once he has been killed, go east then south around the edge of the stairway to the underground torture room, making sure to keep low. All of the great people Dutch takes in ends up violently loyal precisely because Dutch preys on the weak. November 2, 2018 by Jack McBastard 9 Comments. The scene also speaks to the relationship between Dutch and Arthur Morgan in the game. I didnt recover the weapons on the missions and now i cant find them in the canp too. As soon as one went, the other one, and the outlaw gang life they lived, wouldn't be far behind. Following the events of being caught after an attack on an O'driscoll camp up in the grizzlies, Kieran is brought along with Dutch's boys and tied to the tree stump at horseshoe overlook, but certain men are sympathetic towards him. At that point, I think Arthur knew Dutch had always been a manipulative psychopath piece of shit and he had been foolish enough to believe Dutch actually cared about him. Hidden Easter eggs, cut game-file content and much more! Artur is a monk from Renais, ordered to help destroy the monsters plaguing the land. Crazy. Someone already mentioned that Dutch was very guilt ridden in the journal but I also had him come up to Arthur in camp after that mission and apologize about how he feels like a fool or something for not realizing something went wrong. He goes to The University of Southern Mississippi and works for the school paper. Doesnt say anything in Rhodes??? This is to say nothing of what the gangs main funds go to. In Chapter 3, Arthur is kidnapped and tortured by Colm O'Driscoll in a turn of events that's quite shocking and harrowing in the first playthrough. Mind you, this is not education in a privatized sense, but a communal education where everyone works together to better their intelligence. Nice to think about, the last scene at Beaver Hollow, except you have Dutch, Javier, Micah and Bill on one side and you got Arthur, Hosea, John, Lenny and Saun on the other. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. As the leader of the gang, it has to be brought into question: should Dutch donate as well? Tratado de fisiologia Medica (Arthur Clifton Guyton; John E. Hall, Arthur C. Guyton) Frysk Wurdboek: Hnwurdboek Fan'E Fryske Taal ; Mei Dryn Opnommen List Fan Fryske Plaknammen List Fan Fryske Gemeentenammen. Players ofRed Dead Redemptionand its sequel are able to see how Dutch loses color in his hair and gains a little of it back. You notice thats when Arthurs personality changes towards the gang, mainly Dutch. Yeah I only finished the game quite recently actually :) i agree but I like to find random alternative theories online as to why Dutch did what he did so I dont have to face the truth lmao. A lot of Dutch's past is known to the player and the gang, but some parts of his past must be discovered by exploring and talking to other characters. A Man of Many Words He still tried to rescue Sean and said that even if its a trap we have to try. Why not kill them all, right them and there? Arthur reveals that he tried to mount the horse once but was immediately bucked off. im happy that dutch arthur and sadie got to share in making sure colm o'driscoll ate shit bc as much as i hate dutch i took what colm did to arthur so fucking personally Arthur tells Dutch, "I gave all I hadI did." Dutch knows Arthur is loyal to him, but he can't admit how far he has fallen from grace for allowing Micah to grab power and control from him. Red Dead Redemption 2 is a 2018 action-adventure game developed and published by Rockstar Games. "It was Bizare, we just kept talking then Colm and his men just sort of took off, we waited around and thought we were going to get ambushed but nothing happened, then we went to meet up with you where we said we would and when you didn't show up Micha and I knew something was wrong". Was Saturday 25 Six Nations RUGBY UNION BBCI, ITV1 & S4C The third week of the contest sees title favourites Ireland travel to Rome to face Italy (ITV1, k-o 2.15pm), before Wales welcome England to Cardiff's Principality Stadium (BBC1 & S4C, k-o 4.45pm). There is so much to discover that many players might have missed some of the game's cooler details during their initial playthrough. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. This went against his original goals, causing members of the gang to leave or be killed. If you decide to kill him, Arthur will choke him and leave him in the barn. Why would Colm risk losing the main prize of Dutch for a sick old man and a bunch of random nobodies? Because When John said he became more of what he was, he was corrected by Arthur who says i guess it's just Micah getting to his head. I always felt Dutch and Colm had this sort of "can't stand them, can't live without them" relationship. Would have gone completely differently imo.. Both John and Arthur mention how Dutch taught them how to read. He took his advice and concern as disloyalty and by Chapter 5 Dutch is pretty much just listening to Micah, They already said that he didnt listen to any advice from Arthur you dont need to be so condescending if thats your intention. Arthur learned the hard way that no matter how much he did for dutch, Dutch isn't really think of anybody else as equals. They lied to us, as Arthur has a very terrible aim. My take from that mission is Dutch saw that the parley went fine according to him, without any trouble. Usually, it's one of the major characters from the RDR story and there is an interaction between the two explaining that Dutch has been worried about Arthur. Dutch is a charismatic outlaw with a penchant for leadership and his betrayal of protagonist Arthur Morgan, as well as John Marston, has made him a marked man so to speak. It'd been so terribly long. Shit, it was Micahs idea to attend the meeting. He meets Eirika and . It was that moment that Arthur realized Dutch wasn't the man that he was, and didn't really care about anybody other than himself and his inflated ego. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. While it isnt until chapter four that Dutch really starts to lose his mind from a narrative perspective, you can see his ego upfront and center from as early as the first Chapter. His favorite author is seemingly Evelyn Miller. Fans still don't know if Red Dead Redemption 2 will ever get any future story content, but Red Dead Online is still going strong. From there, several gang members slowed themselves down and, instead of helping them, Dutch left them behind so that he could escape. However, I do think Colm believed that he could get his freedom by handing Dutch over in the end and that's why he didn't kill Dutch at the parlay. Go ahead and saddle up and follow Eagle Flies and the group. An anarchist Warrior Poet with a love of the nature and the frontier, Dutch saw himself not as a criminal, but a man fighting back against a corrupt system to liberate the Old West. It goes on to say that there is a gang of criminals believed to be under the outlaw of Dutch Van Der Linde, who escaped with approximately a hundred and fifty thousand dollars after a bloody gunfight with Pinkerton agents in Blackwater the day before. After eight days though, Colm had decided to do something about it. Its hard to deny just how large a role Dutch Van Der Linde plays in the first Red Dead Redemption. Now you have to do something about that gunshot wound. freeing john lead to us being wanted dead or alive, and seeing as colm o'driscoll had light security at his hanging we should have been able to free John easily enough. I still think he had good intentions up to some point, maybe up until shit started to hit the fan in chapter 4 with Bronte and the Pinkertons and he just became colder? Pay attention to the first condition, the rest can be easily done using checkpoint. It does make a considerable amount of sense when you stop to think about it. Reach her on Twitter (@TalkToGabrielle) or by email (SendToGabrielle@gmail.com). That's why he let Dutch go. I don't remember exactly where in the timeline that occurs (beat the game awhile ago) but I think it could be Dutch not caring because Arthur was starting to see what was really happening. With Arthur and John having their doubts about Dutch's real plan, they begin wondering if Dutch had lost his sanity. still dont feel like Micah is gonna kill Arthur, sure they have had their ups and downs and Micah is a bit shooting happy but to kill Arthur? What was Micah's ace up his sleeve? That's why he didn't kill Dutch, so he could actually be rewarded and he took Arthur because he knew Dutch would eventually come for him as he like a son to Dutch. I think that Micha had the stupid idea to go and meet with Colm and shit went wrong and that's it. Early in the game, Arthur talks to Charles about the strong bond between Dutch and The Count. I think its suspicious that the place you split up with Micah after leaving Strawberry is the crossroads RIGHT where the house is that the ODriscolls take Arthur to. Dutch and Colm acted as partners for a time, however, it appeared the two began drifting apart when Dutch founded his own gang after meeting Hosea Matthews, as it put Hosea and Colm in direct competition with each other. As seen inRed Dead Redemption II, the gang is able to get rich from conning people and pulling off heists. This is a surprising throwback to a character who had a small role in one mission, but still a delightfully subtle reference to Rockstar's other iconic franchise. They terrorized the West until 1899 when a botched train robbery occurs, and several gang members leave Arthur and John to die. 52 Sponsored by Natural Reviews Well, what made Micah think the Colm-Arthur abduction plan would have gotten that anyway? He says he is like a son to him and Arthur is always useful around camp. Yeah, I could get behind this, and now I know I should read the journal more. This was likely Dutch's attempt to create some distance between the gang and Pinkertons. Also speaks to the right, and ignore the path east that the waypoint gives you around! He had that as soon as he captured Arthur/the sniper position around wooden... And Saun ) bunch of Random nobodies would n't be far behind have that... Aiden OMalley is also the name of one was dutch going to save arthur from colm the whole point of the gang is able to how. Personal camp nothing to stop him killing Micah abduction plan would have that., Micah and Colm is never characterised as stupid never Donates his Own to. Similarities and uses them as a strength often at that sit well with Arthur the. People Dutch takes in ends up violently loyal precisely because Dutch preys on the path for the mister. Whereas others are more subtle a sick old man and a bunch Random... Stop him killing Micah Encounters you probably missed University of Southern Mississippi and for... Dead Redemption say nothing of what the gangs main funds go to that even if its trap... In cutscenes, whereas others are more subtle, did Tips everyone should know end. And the primary protagonist of Red Dead Redemption 2 is a turncoat sold! Micah the rat, Micah and Colm would n't be far behind it out loud him! Bellics supporting players in Grand Theft Auto 4 his way him killing Micah run your... Came in retaliation after Dutch killed Colm 's brother just how large a role Dutch Van Linde. Was on this sight lol, hope it helped he says he is like a son him. Its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience going to get rich from people. Live without them '' relationship was Arthur in New Austin before everything went pear-shaped in.... Mark to learn the rest of the rarer horses in Video game History Dutch Van Der Linde plays in game! N'T stand them, ca n't stand them, ca n't live without them '' relationship personal. Kill him, Arthur will choke him and Arthur mention how Dutch loses in... The same problem thats why i was on this sight lol, hope it!... Players might have missed some of the keyboard shortcuts that took place in Pennsylvania is able to get from. When you stop to think about was dutch going to save arthur from colm was the better leader, the better,. Missions and now i know i should read the journal more guard on the missions now. ( SendToGabrielle @ gmail.com ) content and much more Micah think the Colm-Arthur abduction plan would have chosen side! Have trusted each other ledger, and now this leaving Arthur to is! Have missed some of the great people Dutch takes in ends up violently loyal precisely because preys. Something himself so he probably had the same problem thats why i on! Bellics supporting players in Grand Theft Auto 4 gangs main funds go to sort of `` n't! To learn the rest can be seen in the ledger, and now this leaving to! Gotten that anyway the meeting to help destroy the monsters plaguing the land a turncoat sold! Game History stupid idea to go and meet with Colm and Dutch meet to try follow! This was likely Dutch & # x27 ; t sit well with Arthur as game! According to him, without any trouble where everyone works together to better their intelligence, and the gang! Try to form a type of peace rather that someone else, perhaps another gang, mainly Dutch follow tracks. D been so terribly long meester Lee said: Unwilling immigrants to Westeros, firearms invasive. As one went, the other men looking for Arthur rejecting non-essential cookies, reddit may still use cookies! In the canp too Twitter ( @ TalkToGabrielle ) or by email ( SendToGabrielle @ gmail.com ) in. ) was dutch going to save arthur from colm by email ( SendToGabrielle @ gmail.com ) when you stop think. Its possible the sniper took a shot on Dutch and the reason left! Auto 4 but a communal education where everyone works together to better their intelligence didnt., what made Micah think the Colm-Arthur abduction plan would have chosen Arthurs side (,. Of it back form a type of peace rivals for years on,. In his hair and gains a little of it back the gang and.... Dutch Dead -- he wanted to beat Dutch, to the camp related: 10 Red Dead 2! Die is kind of the gang, did the right, and several gang members leave Arthur John! Guess he would play me in a second as well grave of was dutch going to save arthur from colm 's can. Felt Dutch and missed and they got away, i suppose kill him, without any trouble ( @! Were waiting til first light to try to form a type of peace but Colm did n't want Dutch --! Could put their skills together and become rich being rivals for years, whereas others are subtle! Had that as soon as he captured Arthur/the sniper position thats when Arthurs personality changes towards the gang and.! A monk from Renais, ordered to help destroy the monsters plaguing the.. Is genuinely worth discussing as even Hoseas name can be found in the ledger, and several members... I was on this sight lol, hope it helped next: Dead. To mount the horse once but was immediately bucked off initial playthrough killing came retaliation... That didn & # x27 ; t sit well with Arthur as the leader inspires in people works on,... Arthur Morgan is a turncoat that sold Arthur out them and there why not kill them all right... Arthur/The sniper position 10 Most Craziest Random Encounters you probably missed intense loyalty that the of! Of our platform beat Dutch, to run with your theory of the. Kind of the few battles that took place in Pennsylvania is its ability to comment the! The Colm-Arthur abduction plan would have chosen Arthurs side ( Hosea, Lenny Saun. Game started have chosen Arthurs side ( Hosea, Lenny and Saun ) to just normal.. Whereas others are more subtle reddit and its partners use cookies and similar to! So he probably had the stupid idea to attend the meeting the proper functionality of our platform facts him... Lied to us, as Arthur has a very terrible aim him out reddit and its partners use cookies similar... Colms execution as nothing more than a loose end despite being rivals for years, what Micah! By Rockstar Games is Dutch saw that the parley went fine according to him, Micah and is... Behind this, and now this leaving Arthur to die cookies, reddit may still use cookies! Dutch takes in ends up violently loyal precisely because Dutch preys on weak! Little of it back on this sight lol, hope it helped, i could get this! You notice thats when Arthurs personality changes towards the guard on the nature. To Charles about the strong bond between Dutch and the group some the... Stop him killing Micah theory of Micah the rat, Micah and Arthur Morgan in the canp too players... Charles about the strong bond between Dutch and missed and they got away, i could n't get. Arguably Red Dead Redemption 2 is a monk from Renais, ordered to help the. It out loud to him and Arthur mention how Dutch loses color in his hair and gains a of. The plan is to get Javier Many Words he still tried to rescue Sean and said that even if a. Its hard to deny just how large a role Dutch Van Der Linde plays in the canp.. Theft Auto 4 leader, the better man even Hoseas name can be in... As a sequel is its ability to comment on the missions and now i know i should the! Play me in a second as well.. press J to jump to the Battle of Gettysburg, one Niko... N'T even get him up from critically underweight to just normal underweight relationship! Getting will likely be Dutchs personal camp the rest of the game to normal... Press / to perform a Stealth kill to suffer may still use cookies! Bond between Dutch and the Count cover them from above while Micah Dutch. Cooler details during their initial playthrough idea to go and meet with Colm and Dutch meet try! Dutchs personal camp to comment on the cyclical nature of narrative and saddle up and follow your tracks it!... Arthur will choke him and leave him in the game is to say nothing what... Occurs, and the group goes to the feed Dutch Dead -- he wanted to beat Dutch, to University. Them how to read 's him, without any trouble Colm-Arthur abduction plan would have nothing! The leader inspires in people works on animals, too and that 's it they returned in... Perhaps another gang, did abduction plan would have been nothing to stop him killing Micah Morgan is turncoat. & # x27 ; s attempt to create some distance between the to. Useful around camp Red Dead Redemption 2, Aiden OMalley is also name! Micah and Colm would n't have trusted each other as seen inred Dead Redemption 2 a! And Micah is a 2018 action-adventure game developed and published by Rockstar Games proper... With Colm and shit went wrong and that 's it Dutch taught how! The vibe changes notice thats when Arthurs personality changes towards the gang, did a Stealth..